So what did you think about tonight??? Who did you like??? Who do you think should be eliminated???

__________________

A recap to refresh your memory....

#1 Luke Menard--"Wake Me Up Before You Go Go"
Okay I thought. I don't think he's bad, but Simon HATES him, so he's doomed.

#2. David Archuleta--"Another Day in Paradise"
I thought he was good, although I didn't think he was the best tonight. Hard for a die-hard groupie to admit.

#3. Danny Noriega--"Tainted Love"
I didn't see all of this, but what I saw wasn't great. He still bugs me too.

#4. David Hernandez--"All Coming Back to Me"
The judges liked him, but I thought he was sharp on the whole song. I think it's the worst he's done so far.

#5. Michael Johns--"Don't You Forget About Me"
I really liked him tonight. Good.

#6. David Cook--"Hello, Is It Me You're Looking For?"
I really liked him tonight too. Good.

#7. Jason Castro--"Hallelujah"
Must admit I've never seen the appeal of him....until tonight. I thought he was great. The best I've liked him.

#8. Chikezie--"She Fills Me Up"
I thought he was good again tonight.

__________________

I cant stand Danny so I hope HIM and Chikeezie, if not than David Hernandez because of the "scandal"

I thought tonight that David Cooke and imo Jason were awesome!

Actually I had a hard choosing because I also liked Michael!

david cook rocked ~ quite literally!

It's soooo hard! That version of "Hello" performed by David Cook was killer!

I think the first guy who sang the Wham song will go home (Luke Menard). I also think the guy with dread locks will go. Chikezie is a toss up.

These are the guys I love:
David Cook
David Archuleta
Danny Noriega
Michael Johns

__________________
NatalieK
Mom to DS's AJ & Benny and DP (darling puppies) Cassie & Shadow

I like David Archuletta, Jason Castro and DANNY! I don't think Danny is the best singer nor do I think he will win. But he has the most personality of all of the guys. He is so flaming homosexual it is funny. Jason Castro is just really cute but the dreadlocks have got to go. David Archuletta is my pick for the top 2 along with Carly Smithson.

__________________
"He that is of the opinion money will do everything may well be suspected of doing everything for money."
Benjamin Franklin

I like Michael Johns, and Jason Castro, but after tonight I am likin David Cook as well! He really rocked!

CANNOT STAND Danny Noriega!! I hope he goes home SOOOOOOON!

David Archuletta and Michael Johns are still my favs, neither did their best tonight, but hey everyone is due a night where they are a little off.....

Davis Cook was good tonight but some of his looks creep me out.

I think Luke and Chikezie will be going.....

1 Luke Menard--"Wake Me Up Before You Go Go"
I never thought his singing was awful, but there is just no appeal to me. He will probably go this week
#2. David Archuleta--"Another Day in Paradise"
I liked it, he will go far

#3. Danny Noriega--"Tainted Love"
My husband can't stand this guy, oddly enough, he doesn't really bug me, except when he is rolling his head around. I think he is ok, and may last this week because votefortheworst.com has picked him

#4. David Hernandez--"All Coming Back to Me"
He usually does ok, I don't think he will last long though

#5. Michael Johns--"Don't You Forget About Me"
My husband thought he sounded awful, and was suprised the judges thought it was good. I think he has something against him. I think he sings good, but I am changed my mind on him being one of my favorites

#6. David Cook--"Hello, Is It Me You're Looking For?"
Awesome. Best one. I want this guy to win

#7. Jason Castro--"Hallelujah"
He was my favorite at first. Don't think he did his best last night, but I still like him, and his John Travolta looks

#8. Chikezie--" He did ok. I think he deserves to at least be in the top 12, but who knows if he will make it.

__________________
"The Christian does not think that God will love us because we are good, but God will make us good because he loves us."- C.S. Lewis

Leigh...What scandel? I like David H and have since Hollywood...is this going to euin it for me?

Danny needs to go home and based on last night Chikezie. Luke might be on the chopping block though b/c like Aliadam pointed out Simon REALLY doesn't like him.

__________________
"When it comes down to it, I let them think what they want. If they care enough to bother with what I do, then I'm already better than them."~ Marilyn Monroe