Not paprika or bay either.

Ack, I should add that I was using the term spice and herb, assuming they meant the same thing. I just realised I used the wrong term since they don't mean the same thing. I'm thinking of an herb.

basil?

Congrats to Liamsmommy! It was basil (probably my fav herb even though none of my recipes ever seem to call for it).

Hooray! I'm having a poopy day so this is perfect timing!!
Now I have to think of something to offer, hmmmmm